Luka Magnotta’s Defense and Baseball Arbitration


Luka Magnotta by Mike McLaughlin / THE CANADIAN PRESS
Luka Magnotta by Mike McLaughlin / THE CANADIAN PRESS

What do Major League Baseball’s arbitration process and a murder trial where the defendant, although having entered a not guilty plea, has admitted to carrying out the heinous acts he has been charged with as in the case of Luka Magnotta have in common? Well ….

Now team management must do an about-face and instead of highlighting the player’s strengths as they usually do, they point out his weaknesses in an attempt to illustrate why he is not worth what he is asking for

With few exceptions, the management of a baseball team usually speaks highly of the team’s players. After all they did hire them, and it’s also good for morale and ticket sales. From time to time players, or more likely their agents, and management attempt to hammer out a new contract. When negotiations hit a wall, when no more dickering or give and take can be taken or given, with neither side prepared to budge, the two sides file for arbitration.

At the hearing the two sides present their cases to the arbiter who then decides on one or the other, winner take all. Now team management must do an about-face and instead of highlighting the player’s strengths as they usually do, they point out his weaknesses in an attempt to illustrate why he is not worth what he is asking for. Not surprisingly his often causes hard feelings between management and players and is a very divisive process.

Luka Rocco Magnotta has been charged with five serious crimes, the most egregious of which is murder. He has stated on record that he did these things, but did not realize they were wrong, on account of his mental illness. His lawyers are trying to convince the jury that he is sick, not a criminal.

In an interesting twist, the defense attorneys in the Magnotta case have had to do an about face of sorts and are currently presenting a litany of medical evidence in an effort to convince the jury that Magnotta should not be held criminally responsible for his acts as at the time …he was suffering from a mental illness.

Much like baseball management usually speaks highly of its players, defense lawyers spend a lot of time praising their clients as good, upstanding citizens who could never have done whatever they have been charged with. Character witnesses and statements are often presented in an attempt to paint a rosy picture of the accused.

In an interesting twist, the defense attorneys in the Magnotta case have had to do an about face of sorts and are currently presenting a litany of medical evidence in an effort to convince the jury that Magnotta should not be held criminally responsible for his acts as at the time he killed, and dismembered his victim Jun Lin he was suffering from a mental illness. This illness, or illnesses allegedly prevented him from understanding that the things he was doing were wrong.  Instead of playing to their client’s strengths, they are forced to hang their case on his illness related anti-social behaviour.

An interesting juxtaposition.

If the case interests you, given the ban on cameras in courtrooms here, aside from next day analysis Twitter – #Magnotta – offers the best live coverage. The Gazette’s Sue Montgomery @MontgomerySue and CBC’s Salimah Shivji @salimah_shivji provide many great updates.

Me DCMontreal – Deegan Charles Stubbs – is a Montreal writer born and raised who likes to establish balance and juxtapositions; a bit of this and a bit of that, a dash of Yin and a soupçon of Yang, some Peaks and an occasional Frean and maybe a bit of a sting in the tail! Please follow DC on Twitter @DCMontreal and on Facebook, and add him on Google+
Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s